Manziel is gone, but the CFL has plenty of good QBs

For someone who lives roughly 1,000 miles from the nearest Canadian border crossing, I’m a little protective of the country.

Scott Adamson writes about alternative pro football leagues because it makes him happy, Follow him on Twitter @adamsonsl

Well, that’s not entirely true – I’m a little protective when it comes to the country’s professional football league. (I’ll trust the Royal Canadian Mounted Police to handle the other stuff).

Anyway, when the Montreal Alouettes announced on Wednesday that Johnny Manziel was off the team and out of the Canadian Football League – permanently – I didn’t bat an eye.

I was even a bit relieved.

While you can argue that Manziel might’ve created more interest in the CFL from fans based in the United States, I never thought his presence was required to make the league better. As far as I’m concerned, the league was already just fine in the QB department, thanks.

Manziel was originally the gridiron property of the Hamilton Tiger-Cats, which set off alarm bells for me. I’m a Ti-Cats fan, and I liked Jeremiah Masoli as the presumptive starting quarterback before the 2018 season. I feared “Johnny Football” would be allowed to step in and take over for no other reason than he once won a Heisman Trophy.

At best, he’d be a distraction.

“We’re excited to add Johnny Manziel to our roster, particularly getting it done now so that Johnny can join his new teammates and the coaching staff for a full training camp,” then-Ti-Cats coach June Jones said at the time. “We feel like we’ve got an excellent group of quarterbacks, and the addition of Johnny only improves our football team in our pursuit of the ultimate goal, which is to win a Grey Cup Championship.”

That was coach-talk, of course, but it didn’t stop me from worrying that Jones would move Manziel to the head of the class – especially after he said he thought Manziel could be one of the best QBs to ever play in the CFL.

Fortunately, it didn’t happen.

Manziel never took a regular season snap for the Tim Hortons Field tenants and was traded to Montreal in July.

Johnny Manziel’s time in the CFL is up. (Dominick Gravel / Alouettes de Montreal photo)

He did get plenty of playing time for the Alouettes – completing 106 of 165 passes for 1,290 yards, five TDs and seven interceptions – but now he’s gone because he, and I’m quoting from the CFL press release here, “… contravened the agreement which made him eligible to play in the league.”

I don’t know what he did and, really, couldn’t care less.

What I do know is the CFL has plenty of quarterbacks who I enjoy watching.

Masoli is my guy because he plays for my team, but it’s not blind loyalty. The dude threw for 5,209 yards and 28 touchdowns last year, and tied a league record for most consecutive 300-plus yardage games with 10.

Like Manziel, he’s dealt with off-the-field issues (second-degree burglary while in college at Oregon and misdemeanor drug and traffic offenses before landing at Ole Miss).

Unlike Manziel, though, he has apparently learned to stay out of trouble and now makes headlines only for what he does on the field.

Mike Reilly is also a boss; he threw for 5,562 yards and 30 touchdowns last year with the Edmonton Eskimos – his second consecutive 30 TD season. This year he’ll be behind center at British Columbia, giving the Lions a turbo boost during his second stint with the franchise.

Calgary’s Bo Levi Mitchell is creeping up on legend status as he engineers the Stampeders’ offense.

In seven seasons with the Horsemen he has thrown for 24,473 yards and 150 touchdowns; last year he accounted for 35 major aerial scores.

Edmonton’s Trevor Harris, Winnipeg’s Matt Nichols, Saskatchewan’s Zach Collaros – the CFL is full of talented and capable signal callers, which is kinda important when you only have three downs to make 10 yards.

And I guess ultimately I like the fact that most of these quarterbacks – even though they harbor NFL dreams – come to Canada and grow as CFL players instead of looking for the nearest exit.

I never got the impression Manziel was fully committed to the league, and that’s why I never caught “Johnny Football Fever.”

Look, I’ve got nothing personal against Manziel. Whatever problems he has I hope he can learn not to “contravene” again. If he gets a chance in the Alliance of American Football this year or the XFL in 2020, I wish him the best.

But when it comes to the Canadian Football League, I don’t need a “big name” to have big fun.

Just show me a field 110 yards long and 65 yards wide, and I’ll trust the players on the field to make it worth my while.

Especially the quarterbacks.

 

Birmingham, Orlando last of the Alliance unbeatens

With a third (give or take a fraction) of the inaugural Alliance of American Football regular season complete, only the Birmingham Iron and Orlando Apollos remain unbeaten.

Birmingham (3-0) has used a smothering defense to mow down Memphis (0-3), Salt Lake (1-2) and Atlanta (0-3), while Orlando (3-0) has been more offense-minded in conquests of Atlanta, San Antonio (1-2) and Memphis.

The Iron gave up 346 yards of total offense but only one touchdown in beating the Legends, 28-12, on Sunday at Georgia State Stadium.

“Our defensive coordinator, Rick Minter, did a fantastic job mixing up the calls and coverages,” Birmingham Coach Tim Lewis said. “We did a good job giving their offensive line all they could handle. Our running back (Trent Richardson) never ceases to amaze me. He’s a very powerful guy who always doesn’t look flashy, but he’s a strong, powerful runner.

“When we had to grind it out, he was able to put his head down and plow into the end zone. It was a tough game that came down to a matter of wills.”

Orlando managed just two TDs in a 21-17 home win over Memphis last Saturday, which caused Apollos boss Steve Spurrier to be muted in his praise of the Eastern Conference co-leaders.

“We feel fortunate to be 3-0,” Spurrier said. “We know the ball has bounced our way the last couple of weeks. We’re trying to improve as the season progresses and if we do that, we’ll have a chance for a big season.

“Offensively last week we weren’t terrible, we just weren’t good.”

SO FAR, SO GOOD

Alliance co-founder Bill Polian was in the press box for Atlanta’s home opener last Sunday, and says the “evolution” of the league’s teams is going about as he expected.

“At this stage of the game the defense is ahead of the offense, and it takes a while to get the offense going,” he said. “It takes a while to get cohesion and get everybody on the same page and I’m sure that will come. I was talking to both (Atlanta and Birmingham) general managers before the game and we’re as close to parity in this league as any I’ve ever been in, which is great.”

Polian suggests that even in football’s top league, offenses rarely find a groove until several games have been played.

“In the NFL it takes until about Week 5 for the offenses to get in sync, and that really shows up in the red zone because everything is much more congested down there,” Polian said. “We’re playing good football and have enthusiastic fans. You hate to say everything is hunky dory, but so far we couldn’t have scripted it any better.”

WATCH OUT FOR THE FLEET

San Diego (2-1) tuned some heads last week with a 31-11 rout of the San Antonio Commanders, avenging a season-opening loss to the Texans and looking like a team ready to make a move.

Ja’Quan Gardner of the San Diego Fleet rushes for a touchdown against the San Antonio Commanders at SDCCU Stadium on Sunday. (Photo by Denis Poroy/AAF/Getty Images)

They now share the Western Conference lead with Arizona (2-1).

The Fleet rolled up 381 yards in total offense and got 202 on the ground in the conquest.

“We’re still a project on offense, but we’re getting better every week,” San Diego Coach Mike Martz said. “Everything seems like it’s coming together a little bit, but it’s not good enough. Everyone is getting better. Those who don’t get better will fall behind pretty quick.”

STRUGGLES IN ATLANTA

The Legends are winless and if you take a look behind the scenes, it’s no wonder.

Original head coach Brad Childress resigned a month before the season started, offensive coordinator Michael Vick was removed from that post two days before the season started, and last Friday acting OC and quarterbacks coach Rich Bartel resigned.

To make matters worse, many of the 10,717 fans who showed up for Sunday’s loss to Birmingham spent much of the day booing starting quarterback Matt Simms and chanting, “We want Murray,” in hopes former Georgia QB Aaron Murray would see action.

He didn’t, but Simms was defiant in the postgame press conference.

“I’ve earned the position that I’m in,” Simms said. “I earn it every day at practice. I earn it every day as far as what we’re asked to do, and I understand the situation – the feelings that some people may have. But at the same time, I’m earning my keep as well.

“I’m going to continue to do that, and continue to be the leader of this team, to be a team captain, and be the quarterback I know I can be when this team gets rolling.”

Simms completed 28 of 48 passes for 328 yards and a TD, but was intercepted three times and sacked twice for 19 yards in losses.

ONSIDE CONVERSION

There are no kickoffs in the Alliance which makes onside kicks rather, uh, difficult.

The solution to the problem comes in the form of an “onside conversion” in which the team that just scored gets a 4th-and-12 play from its own 28.

If the team converts, it maintains possession.

Matt Simms of Atlanta looks to pass against the Birmingham Iron during their game at Georgia State Stadium on Sunday in Atlanta. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/AAF/Getty Images)

Atlanta will go down in history as the first AAF team to have a successful onside “non-kick.” After the Legends scored in the fourth quarter to pull within 16 of Birmingham, Simms completed a 48-yard pass that allowed the Legends to maintain possession.

Alas, Simms was picked off on the following play to end the drive and ultimately make the unique play inconsequential.

ALL IS WELL

There were widespread reports suggesting the $250 million Tom Dundon committed to the Alliance of American Football recently was done to bail out a sinking league.

League CEO and co-founder Charlie Ebersol quickly said those reports were wrong and Dundon backed him up.

The owner of the National Hockey League’s Carolina Hurricanes officially became the chairman of the board of the Alliance last Tuesday, and says his monetary contribution is to help the spring league thrive, not merely survive.

“As a lifelong sports fan and entrepreneur, I’ve always valued the opportunities generated in the ecosystem of sports and entertainment,” Dundon said. “I’m impressed with the Alliance’s stunning growth in-stadium and across TV, mobile and social media in just these first few weeks.”

Ebersol said the AAF always planned to bring in more investors, and Dundon was certainly a huge get.

“Since the beginning, it has been crucial that the foundation of the Alliance be set with world-class partners, and Tom Dundon represents just that,” Ebersol said. “Tom, Bill (Polian), and I will work with our great team at the Alliance to expand our football operations and technology business.”

PLAYERS OF THE WEEK

Offense: San Diego RB Ja’Quan Gardner (122 rushing yards, 1 TD).

Defense: San Diego RB A.J. Tarpley (5 tackles, INT return for TD).

Special teams: Birmingham P Colton Schmidt (5 punts, 49.2 yard average).

UP NEXT

Saturday it’s San Diego at Memphis (4 p.m. EST, BR/Live) and Orlando at Salt Lake (8 p.m. EST, NFL Network) while on Sunday San Antonio is at Birmingham (4 p.m. EST, CBS Sports Network), and Atlanta travels to Arizona (8 p.m. EST, NFL Network).

Follow Scott Adamson on Twitter @adamsonsl. He can be reached by email at [email protected].

Birmingham topples Atlanta, 28-12

By Scott Adamson
Adamsonmedia.com

ATLANTA, Ga. – Pro football teams representing Atlanta and Birmingham crossed paths on the gridiron for the first time on Sunday. And after all the work was done at Pete Petit Field at Georgia State Stadium, the Magic City owned a little piece of history.

Trent Richardson celebrates a touchdown run against the Atlanta Legends during their game at Georgia State Stadium on Sunday in Atlanta. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/AAF/Getty Images)

With the defense delivering another stellar performance, Luis Perez passing effectively when it was necessary, and Trent Richardson continuing his role as designated scorer, Birmingham exited with a 28-12 victory before an announced crowd of 10,717.

The Iron improves to 3-0 on the season, joining the Orlando Apollos as the only unbeaten teams left in the Alliance of American Football’s inaugural season.

Atlanta slips to 0-3 and shares the Eastern Conference cellar with Memphis – Birmingham’s Week One victim.

“I thought our guys ground it out and lived up to our name, Iron – I think we’re a tough football team,” Birmingham Coach Tim Lewis said. “We’re resilient, we’re strong, we bend but we don’t break. The guys did a fantastic job today.”

Perez hit 17 of 31 passes for 160 yards and one interception, with Quinton Patton leading all Iron receivers with four catches for 58 yards.

Atlanta’s Matt Simms, on the other hand, completed 28 of 48 passes for 328 yards and a touchdown, but also tossed three interceptions and was sacked three times for 25 yards in losses.

Beniquez Brown was in on 12 tackles to pace the victors while Max Redfield, Jack Tocho and Jamar Summers picked off one pass each.

“Beniquez also forced a fumble, and our field goal kicker did a great job again,” Lewis said.

Leading 9-6 at the break, a 27-yard Nick Novak field goal at 8:20 of the third quarter gave the eventual winners a 12-6 edge.

And with five seconds to go in the third, Richardson capped off a 12 play, 62-yard march with a 1-yard plunge – and also converted the 2-point play – to make it 20-6 at :05 of the third quarter.

Atlanta’s last, best shot to get back in the game came when Perez was picked off deep in Birmingham territory, giving the Legends first down at the Iron 11. However, they went backward from there, and a fourth down sack kept the lead at 14.

“We did a really good job in the red zone,” Lewis said. “We took the ball away from them a couple of times.”

The Atlanta Legends huddle during their Alliance of American Football game against the Birmingham Iron at Georgia State Stadium on Sunday in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Logan Riely/AAF/Getty Images)

A Summers INT of a Simms pass midway through the fourth gave the Iron a chance to end all doubt,  and they did just that when Richardson highlighted a 17-yard mini-drive with a 6-yard scoring jaunt 4:28 from the finish.

“It’s amazing and a blessing, and I don’t take it for granted,” said Richardson, who finished the day with 46 yards on 17 carries for three touchdowns and a 2-point conversion. “Just to be out there on that field and with a group of guys I call my brothers is amazing. To have a group of guys that are just hungry is something beautiful.”

Atlanta got an “Oh, by the way” score late in the fourth and the Legends also successfully completed an “onside conversion” that gave them the ball back after the score.

But Simms was picked off in the end zone by Redfield and that put the finishing touches on a 28-12 game.

“I told our guys after the game I’m disappointed for them, not disappointed in them,” Atlanta boss Kevin Coyle said. “They’re working as hard as they can and we want to get this thing turned around as quick as we can, and I think we will.”

The first 30 minutes was far from pretty, with the teams combining for 11 penalties totaling 123 yards.

But there was some solid slobber-knocking on both sides.

“The first half was anybody’s game,” Lewis had. “We had to grind it out and battle it out to get this ‘W.’ We’ll meet that team again and with the talent on that team, they’ll be ready to go.”

On the first drive of the contest, the Birmingham defense did what the Birmingham defense tends to do – keep its opponents off the board.

Atlanta looked good to take the lead with a nice mix of running and passing, making it as deep as the Iron 1.

But the Legends got no further.

On a fourth-and-three feet play, Simms misfired a pass intended for tight end Bug Howard, and the visitors took over.

Following a stop, Atlanta was at it again, and once more the hosts knocked on the door.

But a motion penalty turned a third-and-4 into a third-and-9, and the Legends managed to make up just six yards before calling out Younghoe Koo.

Koo’s 21-yard field goal was good, and Atlanta was on top, 3-0, early in the second quarter.

Birmingham made just enough plays to get into scoring range after falling behind, and answered with a 39-yard Novak field goal.

It was 3-3 with 10:27 left in the half, and a defensive struggle was brewing.

Yet with flags flying at a rapid rate, it was appropriate that a huge penalty finally led to a touchdown.

Perez overthrew DeVozea Felton on a deep ball but Atlanta was called for interference, and the resulting spot foul was worth 55 yards and put the Iron on the Legends’ 10.

Two plays later Richardson went over right guard from five yards out, and Birmingham was in front.

Two straight motion penalties made the conversion a 12-yard try, and Perez threw incomplete to leave the score at 9-3.

More penalties helped put Simms and company in business on the ensuing drive, but it fizzled out at the 17.

Koo salvaged three points with a 35-yard field goal, and that ending scoring in the opening half with the Iron ahead, 9-6.

The Legends didn’t score again until the game was well out of reach.

“We had three chances down in the red zone and didn’t come away with touchdowns,” Coyle said. “We had some turnovers in the second half and before you knew it, the game was lost.

But this is a helluva group of young men, and we’re going to get this thing turned around.”

Birmingham hosts San Antonio next Sunday at 4 p.m., while Atlanta travels to Arizona on Sunday for an 8 p.m. start.