
Although the fledgling Continental Football League didn’t play its first regular season game until August 14, 1965, the COFL saw a flurry of activity in late April of that year.
Between April 27 and April 28, the Rhode Island Indians named Mickey Connolly its head coach; Babe Dimancheff took the same job with the Philadelphia Bulldogs; and Continental League president Happy Chandler (former commissioner of Major League Baseball) was about to embark on a tour of the circuit’s franchises.

However, it was a battle between the COFL’s Hartford Charter Oaks and Holyoke Bombers of the Atlantic Coast Football League that made minor league football a major news story during baseball season.
First, some background.
The flagship franchises of the Continental League were the Charleston Rockets, Fort Wayne Warriors, Hartford, Newark Bears, Norfolk Neptunes, Philadelphia, Rhode Island, Richmond Rebels, Toronto Rifles and Wheeling Ironmen.
Hartford, Newark, Norfolk (originally the Springville Acorns before moving to Virginia) and Richmond broke away from the ACFL (formed in 1962) to join the COFL, while Wheeling and Charleston became members after the United Football League folded. Toronto, Philly and Ft. Wayne were relocated from their previous UFL cities (Montreal, Canton and Indianapolis, respectively).
Rhode Island was the only “new” team.
The 1965 ACFL lineup featured the Boston Steamrollers, Harrisburg Capitols, Holyoke, Jersey Jets, Mohawk Valley Falcons, New Bedford Sweepers, Pittsburgh Valley Ironmen and Scranton Miners.
Mike Mosolf, a 6-1 quarterback, had spent time with the Dallas Cowboys, Indianapolis Warriors (during their UFL days) and Canadian Football League Ottawa Rough Riders before starring with Hartford in 1964.
During the Charter Oaks’ farewell season in the ACFL, he passed for 976 yards, 10 touchdowns and nine interceptions while rushing for 312 yards in leading Hartford to an 8-6-1 record. He was also an outstanding punter.
The Charter Oaks expected the 25-year-old to be their field general again as the club switched leagues in 1965, but on April 27, Holyoke owner Socco Babacas announced Mosolf had signed with the Bombers.
This news blindsided Don Brewer, general manager of the Hartford side.
“We’re truly disappointed,” Brewer told the Hartford Courant. “Actually, we’re shocked over Mike’s decision. We were completely unaware of Mike’s decision to play with Holyoke. We felt we had treated him as fairly as possible.
“We feel that Mike has a moral and legal obligation toward the Oaks and we have turned the situation over to our lawyers. He signed with us legally. He agreed with our first contract when we were still a member of the ACFL and later signed a second contract when we officially joined the Continental League.”
Holyoke was given draft rights over Hartford players when the Charter Oaks withdrew from their old league. And Babacas said the bylaws of the ACFL state that the contracts of players in that league still belong to the league if a club resigns.
“I’m in the right,” Babacas said in an interview with the Courant on May 3, 1965. “I’m not worried about being right or wrong. I talked to (NFL commissioner Pete Rozelle) and he says I have nothing to worry about.”
T. Owen Eagen, attorney for the Hartford group, disagreed.
“In resigning from the league voluntarily,” he said, “the Charter Oaks took proper legal steps to protect their players. I feel sorry for (Mosolf). He messed himself up signing all these contracts. You can’t force anybody to play for you, but you can prevent him from playing for someone else. This is not out of a spirit of vindictiveness, but we must make them honor contracts.”
The Continental League certainly didn’t want one of its first major news flashes to come from a courtroom, but it happened. On May 20, Judge Francis J. Quirico issued a temporary injunction ordering Mosolf to play for the Charter Oaks. The Patriot-News reported that in Mosolf’s testimony he said that he considered the Hartford contract “ineffective” because the franchise didn’t complete it by entering the amount he was to be paid for each game.
A hearing on the merits of the case was slated for July 26 – less than three weeks from the start of the COFL season – but on July 22, Mosolf agreed to terms with the Charter Oaks and the legal part of the saga effectively ended.
“He advised us that he would like to rejoin the Charter Oaks for the 1965 season,” Brewer said. “He feels that his decision to sign with another club was ill-advised, and he has expressed to us his regrets for the problems the actions have caused the personnel of this ballclub.”
Turns out, there were no happy endings for either team – or the quarterback they both wanted.
The Charter Oaks finished 2-12 and last in the COFL West.
Mosolf’s campaign resulted in just 325 yards through the air, two touchdowns and three INTS, although he continued to handle punting duties. By the time the season was done the team had put several different players behind center. Lee Grosscup (who became a successful broadcaster who covered everything from the American Football League to the original USFL) played the most, tossing for 1,456 yards, 10 TD and 15 interceptions.
Grosscup also briefly served as player/coach after Hartford boss Fred Wallner resigned in September.
Holyoke logged a 2-9-1 worksheet, bad enough for last place in the ACFL Northern Division. Jerry Whelchel started at QB for the Bombers, finishing with 1,844 yards and 15 touchdown passes against 13 picks.